WHEN you become aware of how the Botswana Government have treated with disdain, their own sacred San people, a tiny race that is upheld and revered throughout the world, which until recently survived centuries without disease and through drought, one cannot but help question that country’s Presidential actual policies?
These racist policies however, have become more relevant to Zimbabweans throughout the world since the Government of Botswana announced that it“does not recognize Robert Mugabe as President of Zimbabwe” and has been instrumental in supporting the terrible sanctions which are affecting the very man they have purported to support in the streets of Zimbabwe.
Few realised at the time that, behind the diplomatic smiles, as has become apparent now, that this included the entire nation of Zimbabwe’s immigrants.Is it poetic justice that since their original proclamation, Botswana’s Ministry of Health has admitted that on the back of HIV/AIDS pandemic, TB infections have greatly increased?
It is obvious that this is because the Botswana Government have specifically excluded assisting Zimbabweans access to the country’s free public health system, and all because of a decision based on who the President of Zimbabwe is. The question do other immigrants to Botswana from Angola, Congo, Kenya and Somalia automatically access its free health system?
Refugees and asylum seekers who might be suffering from TB infections could have been be saved from a fate worse than death, if only the enriched Botswana Government had extended their benevolence to include housing, food and clean clothes, but instead their negative attitude has manifested a breeding ground for infectious and communicable diseases throughout Botswana - right on their doorstep? Is it time yet to declare Botswana an Infectious Diseases colony so that its nationals must flaunt relevant inoculations and health certificates, or is its Government keeping its true state of health under wraps?
With its western residents and diplomats upholding Botswana, it is not exactly a third world state in a developing world. In fact, the Central Statistical Office (BW) shows that, despite sanctions against Zimbabwe, during Zimbabwe’s Presidential Elections that country exported 5.1 percent of Botswana’s total exports to Zimbabwe! One assumes that as these were business deals, capitalising on the broken back of Zimbabwe’s struggling economic crisis, done through the back door during a world organised sanctions era in which one has little regard for its victims but is focused merely on making an instant profit, every fast buck will count.
Exports to Zimbabwe, according to Botswana’s Sunday Standard, were in fact 1.3 percentmore than its exports to China during March 2008,
confirming that “Exports to Zimbabwe were valued at P155.7 million while those received by China were valued at P116.1 million! On the other hand, the combined total of goods exported to France, Germany, Belgium, Greece, Netherlands, Sweden and Portugal came to P71.3 million.”In fact, it is now common knowledge that Botswana exports more goods than any other African country to Zimbabwe!
It was surprising therefore, that a decision was made to eliminate Zimbabwe from the Memorandum of Understanding with Zambia and Botswana over construction of the US$70m Kazungula Bridge Project. This far-reaching decision only increased the three-way political tension with Zambia taking sides with Botswana, but perhaps it was a decision made to show the world (that, on the face of it) Botswana means business when it comes to supporting the sanctions in its dealings with Zimbabwe.
Were sanctions to be lifted tomorrow, it would be no surprise to learn that Botswana has reverted to its original agreement to now include Zimbabwe but only obviously, because without sanctions, there could now be even greater trade between Botswana and Zimbabwe, i.e. > P155.7m!
With the SADC borders in the region only recently opening up, prices in the local supermarkets and wholesalers have doubled, and Botswana nationals are no longer happy because they now find themselves in a similar situation to Zimbabweans.
It is not surprising because suddenly the very commodities, which once graced their boastful shelves, now having been purchased and hauled across the borders to northern states, are no longer available in Botswana but are seemingly available in none other than Zimbabwe itself!
Padding a gaping wound with PR wadding as the world watches, while the patient continues to haemorrhage severely, has apparently been the attitude of Botswana to its foreign immigrants, but over a period it would now appear that as a result Botswana has “shot itself in the foot” especially in disregarding its closest neighbour’s real predicaments in preference to supporting anti-western policies, despite the paternal President Mbeki urging Botswana to be more proactive in solving Zimbabwe’s crisis.
Ultimately this week, by agreeing in the Botswana High Court, to provide medication to the Zimbabwean deportee Mtandazo Sibanda’s, the result is that this Court is likely to find itself inundated with suits from many more immigrants appealing against deportation, while at the same time suing the Botswana Government and claiming treatment for Multi-Drug Resistant Tuberculosis (MDR-TB).
Until now Sibanda was just another anonymous statistic in the prison clinics of Botswana, but since his removal to Princess Marina’s Hospital to begin treatment, his case is fast becoming a monumental historical landmark, and one wonders whether other immigrants from countries such as Angola, Somalia and the Congo, will now be taking the Botswana Government for an unprecedented long ride that could have been nipped in the bud when they first arrived in the country seeking sustenance, a warm dry sanctuary beneath a roof over their head during the bitterly cold winters and an attitude of compassion which they claim they were denied in their own destabilised countries, an attitude that was practiced and perfected against an innocent San people, by a supposedly sophisticated and knowledgeable President, Ian Seretse Khama, a President who was warned by his own government against making derogatory statements about its key trading partner with deep friendship roots. One cannot but help compare this man with George Bush Jnr., another infamous son who himself has failed to walk in his own father’s footsteps.
TRUTH SERUM • na Subject: You got it wrong. Mon, 08 Sep 2008 14:44:13 • Ian Khama has only been President since April 2008.
There is problem with the San and although they won their case (in Dec 2006) the situation is ongoing.
With regard to health, non citizens are not entitled to free health care, it does not matter where you are from. We can use the government facilities at a much reduced rate however the level of care is average. Before we had an ophthalmologist in the private sector John had a problem with his eyes and was referred to the State Ophthalmologist, he went to the eye clinic and was charged the princely sum of P2.50 (25p) which included 2 visits. TB and XDR are public health issues and as such if you are living here legally, are a registered refugee or have been granted asylum you are entilted to free treatment. Mr Sibanda was being deported because he at one stage refused treatment, left his voluntarily confinement and was a danger to the public. He might as well have had an AK and shot anyone within spitting distance. He dropped the case on the 05/09 because he is not prepared to be isolated for economic reasons and will thus be sent back to Zim. The health dept. are very strict with all the TB cases and they are all monitored very carefully, all patients regardless of nationality are the same. The incidence of TB is decreasing although very slowly.
Refugees are housed, fed and have full access to the gov. clinic for any ailment.
With regard to HIV, there are a number of NGO's who offer free testing etc for non citizens.
Botswana is a NETT importer. There are no government trade sanctions between Botswana and Zimbabwe, we can import/export anything we want, providing of course it is legal and exports paid for in forex. Botswana's main export to Zim is Nickel because we have no smelter here, the rest is probably visitors buying groceries and taking them home. The building industry used to import cement, bricks, window frames and timber but because of erratic deliveries and substandard products these are now being manufactured locally or sourced from SA.
I am not sure what you mean by 'SADC borders in the region only recently opening up' SA and Bots have had a common customs union for years. Our prices in the Supermarkets and Industry have not doubled except for rice, steel, petrol and its by products all of which are a worldwide problem at the moment. Here in Gabs we can buy 99% of what we need, our shelves are always full and if what we want is not available locally we just import it. Our petrol is only P5.50/litre equivalent to 50p.
The decision to leave Zim out of the Kazangula Bridge Project has nothing to do with trade sanctions, it has to do with the border dispute in which Zim claim that the area in Zambia along Kazangula belongs to them. Because of the dispute and delays Zambia had a $60 million loan witheld, ADB withdrew funding so to avoid losing more money the Bridge will now go over Namibian waters instead. Zimbabwe basically shot themselves in the foot because of their demands and shortsightedness..
I notice that you did quote the The Sunday Standard. This week it published 2 retractions and apologies which indicates the level of reporting. They opt for sensationalism and not fact. We have only ever bought it twice (yesterday being one instance). The most unbiased and reliable newspaper here is the Mmegi and that we only buy for the legal section. They published a statement from the Ministry of health regarding Sibanda and can be accessed on line.
The Liberal • n/a Subject: Ignorance Wed, 03 Sep 2008 03:36:44 • Botswana leaders seem sadly misguided in their short term thinking as the article shows. They are intent on sanctioning their biggest trading partner were they have a trade surplus since Zim imports more than it exports that country.
If Zim is their biggest trading partner after almost 10 years of sanctions, what does it really say about the Botswana economy.
To me it now seems their wealth is a myth coz when Zim was good they were not our biggest trading partner and a tour round their country will show infrastructure that`s not up to scratch.
The likely fall out from all this when the crisis in Zim is over will be Zimbabweans who resent Botswana and obviously affecting trade. I remember a previous diplomatic row which almost affected trade and Quett Masire had to rush over to reason with Bob.
I feel their oportunistic leader who did not even face a ballot cannot really be a champion of the ballot when he is part of a de facto junta that disregards the Botswana voters and instead are promoted to presidency like private companies
zana • ndhlela@sbcglobal.net Subject: Stop dreaming Zimbabwe is now a nation of beggars Mon, 01 Sep 2008 15:19:58 • What is the point of this article? Zimbabwbwe needs botswana more than botswana needs Zimbabwe. how much food currently crosses from Botswana to Zimbabwe. it started as small 'luxury' items and moved to bigger things like petrol/diesel . Now the very items necessary for survival -food comes from there . stop dreaming Zimbabwe is now a country of beggars.Just go see how many illegal zimbabweans are walking the streets of botswana looking for piece jobs to feed their folk. or how many zimbabweans would jump at a job offer even doing the most menial of tasks. this situation is true for zimbabweans everywhere.
What good is an education if it can not give you a living in your own country? Working in a foreign country is not wonderful like you fools think no matter what your job is . Zimbabwe is not wonderful stop fooling yourself. All these people in the diaspora are not in zimbabwe because it is not wondeful. It took me a long time to realise and admit that zimbabwe is propbably the worst country in the world right now. Get this EVEN THE POOREST HAVE A COUNTRY WHERE THEY HAVE FREEDOM FOOD AND HEALTH INSTITUTIONS THAT WORK
Botswana can afford to pay those who go there who are foreigners . Zimbabwe cannot pay them and has no control on who works where. Try starving your kids and see if any of them give you parental respect.Zimbabwe USED to be bigger NOT ANYMORE. Thanks to MUgabe and Zanu. We are now beggars everywhere.
Ndimi vanhu vanovhaira ne the few US$,Pounds or rands your folks send you after suffering so much to get it doing menial jobs and then believe zimbabwe is wonderful.Why do you not aspire to have eveybody home and still be able to function as a country? if you are so shallow answer this were all of us from around the world to come back can zimbabwe feed us? if not then you are extremely foolish. Kutsavaga mabasa munyika dzevamwe is still begging.
the Kabaka • laurance_lawduk@hotmail.com Subject: Winds of Change in Bots Sat, 30 Aug 2008 13:16:06 • Interesting read. I am sure this Khama is a dictator himself.
n/a • vhusani@comone.co.zw Subject: Ian's IQ is........... Sat, 30 Aug 2008 04:06:47 • iam suprised, what exports are we talking about from Botswana, in actual fact Zimbabwean manpower is key to that economy, TSWANAS are not educated, we are supporting that economy, the Mazoe products, cooking oil to name a few are products from Zimbabwe, and dominating in the their supermarkets. These Tswanas are worse than third world, their overzealousness cannot teach Zimbabwe any democratic principles, they should name their masters who are sending them to demonise us, as if their Khama thing was elected, Mogae was more of leader than this fake army general, who thinks democracy in Africa starts and ends in Botswana, wait till we recover economically, all our educated manpower will come home and leave these ungrateful morons alone, at least Mogae was gentleman enough when he paid tribute to the women and men of the beautiful Zimbabwe for helping their economy with expertise and skilled manpower.I used to shop in Gaborone, i since stopped, i cant stand these misinformed idiots from the border to the shops. Zimbabwe is by far superior than this farmland who thrives on grants in return for bitching about Zimbabwe, leave us alone idiots, get educated first and smell the truth.
el bantu • na.@zol.co.zw Subject: ZIM IS THE GELLING FACTOR! Fri, 29 Aug 2008 07:05:19 • Ha ha that is so funny - that appointed 'idiot chief' (most presidents are elected one way or another) is so much of a puppet! You do realise that they export a large propotion of their electricity from Cabora Bassa? Guess how it gets to them......... through Zim of course!
SUBMITYOUROPINION
Please make sure you fill in all sections for your post to be submitted. Use n/a if not submitting details. The submission code below is case-sensitive. Also make sure you get confirmation that your comment has been submitted.